AI and Copyright
Part 1 (in class, 20 minutes): Can the system tell?
Copyright detectors such as Content ID work by fingerprinting an upload and
comparing it to a reference. Today’s content is machine-made. In pairs, with a
laptop and a phone, run three short experiments. Each has exact steps; write
down what you see.
Experiment 1: Does the model recite? (5 minutes)
A Munich court held in 2025 that ChatGPT reciting song lyrics verbatim was a
copyright reproduction, in a suit brought by GEMA, Germany’s music rights
society (the ASCAP/BMI equivalent).
- Open two chatbots (for example ChatGPT and
Claude, or UChicago’s Phoenix).
- Ask each for the complete lyrics of “Let It Be” by the Beatles.
- Ask each for the complete lyrics of “Männer” by Herbert Grönemeyer (a GEMA
artist named in the ruling).
- Ask each for the first paragraph of Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s
Stone.
- For each answer note: recited in full, quoted a few lines, summarized, or
refused. Is the behavior a rule about lyrics, about copyright generally, or
about particular rightsholders?
Experiment 2: Does the file say where it came from? (7 minutes)
C2PA “content credentials” are an industry standard for a signed record,
embedded in an image or video file, of how it was made and edited, including
whether a model generated it. Several image generators sign their output.
- Generate an image with ChatGPT or Gemini (any prompt) and download it to
your laptop as a file.
- Upload the file to the verifier at
verify.contentauthenticity.org.
Does it show credentials, and do they say an AI tool made it?
- Take a screenshot of the same image and upload the screenshot. What
happened to the credentials?
- Upload a photo taken with your own phone. Does it carry any credentials?
- Note: who, in practice, ends up with a provenance record, and who does not?
Experiment 3: Does the fingerprinter recognize it? (7 minutes)
Shazam identifies music the way Content ID does: a fingerprint of the audio,
matched against a reference library of released recordings.
- On YouTube, search for “Suno AI song” or “Udio AI song” and open a video
that is clearly a machine-generated track.
- Look under the video description for YouTube’s “Altered or synthetic
content” label. Is it there?
- Play the track and run Shazam (or Google’s “What’s this song?”) on your
phone. Does it identify anything? If it names a real song, is that song
actually what you heard?
- Do the same for a well-known released song. Compare.
- Note: the AI track may have been made by a model trained on licensed
catalogues (the Warner and Universal deals). Who is its rightsholder, and
what could a Content ID reference for it even be?
Report back (one minute per pair)
The one result that surprised you, and whether it moves you toward “the
detectors can handle machine-made content” or “they were built for a world
that no longer exists.”
Read one platform’s current policy on AI-generated content (YouTube’s
AI page, Spotify’s AI policy,
or Meta’s AI labels) and write three sentences on what it detects, what it
asks the uploader to self-declare, and what happens when neither works.